| Student | Grade | Position | Year |
| Dayo Origunwa | 11 | 1st Team Forward | 2012 |
| John Halifax | 12 | 2nd Team Midfielder | 2012 |
| Teo Nugent | 11 | 2nd Team Striker | 2011 |
| Michael Beleson | 12 | 2nd Team Defense | 2011 |
| Nick Zatopa | 12 | 1st Team Goalie | 2011 |
| Austin Fusco | 10 | 2nd Team Defense | 2009 |
| Pietro Carini | 12 11 |
2nd Team Defense 1st Team Defense |
2010 2009 |
| Oscar Bonilla | 12 10 |
1st Team Forward 2nd Team Forward |
2010 2008 |
| Kyle Walenga | 12 | 2nd Team Midfield | 2008 |
| Joe Kuhel | 12 | 2nd Team Defense | 2008 |
| Alex Zatopa | 12 11 |
2nd Team Goalkeeper 2nd Team Goalkeeper |
2008 2007 |
| Martin Jackson | 12 | 2nd Team Forward | 2007 |
| Arran Caddy | 12 10 |
BCL Central MVP 2nd Team Defense |
2008 2006 |
| Peter Siegenthaler | 12 11 10 |
1st Team Defense 2nd Team Defense 2nd Team Defense |
2008 2007 2006 |
| Henry Whitaker | 12 | 1st Team Forward | 2005 |
| Tilo Artiga-Purcell | 12 9 |
1st Team Forward 2nd Team Midfield |
2005 2002 |
| Lukas Schubsda | 12 11 |
1st Team Midfield 1st Team Midfield |
2006 2005 |
| Jonas Harris | 12 11 9 |
1st Team Defense 1st Team Defense 2nd Team Defense |
2008 2007 2005 |
| Ted Brennan | 12 | 2nd Team Defense | 2005 |
| Oscar Azucena | 11 | 2nd Team Mid/Keeper | 2005 |
| Brendan David | 12 11 |
1st Team Defense 2nd Team Midfield |
2004 2003 |
| Carlos Huertas | 11 | 2nd Team Forward | 2004 |
| Morgan Jenkins | 12 11 |
1st Team Forward 1st Team Midfield |
2003 2002 |
| Michael Paul Stauffer | 10 | 2nd Team Defense | 2003 |
| Alisdair Sun | 10 | 2nd Team Defense | 2002 |
